Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over Facebook Camera Roll Access
The Italian Data Protection Authority, known as the Guarantor, has fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited €805 million over the way Facebook’s Android app accessed users’ camera rolls. The case concerns photographs, videos, and related metadata stored on smartphones belonging to users in Italy.
The investigation focused on Facebook’s “Get camera roll suggestions when you’re browsing Facebook” feature. Introduced in 2023, the feature suggests photos and videos from a user’s phone as possible content for Facebook posts. The Guarantor found that the feature could access camera roll content without sufficiently specific and informed consent.
According to the Authority, Facebook used a single Android permission covering several functions with different purposes. Before the permission was requested, users saw a general notice referring to “other features.” The notice did not clearly explain that accepting the permission could also activate suggestions based on content stored in the camera roll.
The Guarantor also found that the feature was enabled by default. Once the relevant permission was granted, the app could access the user’s entire photo library, generally on an ongoing basis. The Authority stated that users and regulators could not verify precisely which information was accessed or used.
The decision is based on Article 122 of the Italian Data Protection Code, which implements requirements under the EU ePrivacy Directive. The provision protects information stored on a person’s device as part of their private sphere. The Guarantor emphasized that access to such information requires free and informed consent, even where the data is not transmitted to another party and no proven harm has occurred.
Meta argued that the Irish data protection authority should have jurisdiction. The Italian Guarantor rejected this position, explaining that the ePrivacy Directive does not include the GDPR’s one-stop-shop mechanism. The proceedings did not examine whether camera roll content was used to train artificial intelligence systems. Meta denies that it used the content for that purpose.
The Guarantor has ordered Meta to make several changes within 60 days. The company must request consent through a separate and specific notice for the camera roll suggestion feature. It must also explain the feature’s purpose, the consequences of granting access, and how users can disable it. The feature must remain disabled by default, including for users who previously granted the relevant device permission.
If Meta does not comply, it may not enable the feature for users who have not provided valid consent. The company must report the initiatives it has undertaken within 30 days and provide details of the measures adopted within 90 days. The Authority also reserved the right to examine a newer feature launched in 2026 that processes camera roll content in the cloud.
When setting the end, the Guarantor considered the estimated number of affected users, approximately 20 million Android users in Italy. It also considered the duration of the alleged violation, a previous decision against Meta in 2019, and the company’s limited cooperation during the investigation. Changes made after the complaint were treated as mitigating factors, although they were introduced late and applied only to users who updated the app. The end represents approximately 0.47% of Meta’s global turnover.