EDPS Calls for Effective Safeguards in EU-US Border Data Exchange
On September 10, 2026, the European Commission proposed a framework agreement between the European Union and the United States for exchanging information related to border checks, travel authorisations, and visas. The proposed framework would establish common conditions for reciprocal data sharing between EU Member State authorities and US authorities.
The arrangement would support identity verification, traveller screening, and security checks. Authorities could use exchanged information to assess whether a person’s entry presents a serious and genuine risk to public security or public order. The proposal may also involve the exchange of sensitive personal data, including biometric information.
The United States has required countries participating in its Visa Waiver Program to conclude an “Enhanced Border Security Partnership” with the US Department of Homeland Security by the end of 2026. For this reason, the European Commission has proposed applying the agreement provisionally before its formal entry into force.
The European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS) has issued its opinion warning that effective safeguards must be in place before the framework is applied. Wojciech Wiewiórowski, the European Data Protection Supervisor, described the proposal as the first EU arrangement involving the exchange of personal data, potentially including biometric data, with a third country on this scale for border control purposes.
The EDPS recommends carefully selecting the national information systems used for the exchange. Only information that is relevant and strictly necessary should be shared. The future bilateral agreements should also clearly define which offences may create a risk to public order or public security.
The agreements should specify when a person has a sufficient “nexus” to an EU Member State or to the United States. This connection should be concrete, verifiable, and proportionate to the purpose of the data exchange. Authorities should also establish an objective link between the identified risk and the individual concerned on a case-by-case basis.
As a general rule, the authority requesting information should explain why it believes that the individual may present a risk. Where specific reasons cannot be provided, it should at least identify the nature of the suspected risk. Authorities sharing information should also receive effective notification when the data is subsequently shared with another authority.
The EDPS has further called on the European Commission to monitor whether affected individuals can obtain effective judicial redress in practice, regardless of their citizenship or nationality. The Commission should also monitor serious human rights violations and consider suspending or terminating the agreement where necessary.
The proposed framework identifies the data protection authorities of EU Member States as oversight bodies. However, the EDPS considers that the US supervisory arrangements require greater clarity. Before provisional application begins, the United States should formally notify the EU of the authorities responsible for supervision, their specific duties and powers, and any later changes to those arrangements.
The proposal illustrates the legal and practical challenges of large-scale international data transfers for border control. Compliance will depend on clear limits, independent oversight, effective remedies, and demonstrable necessity and proportionality. The EDPS’s recommendations are intended to ensure that security cooperation does not weaken the fundamental rights of people whose data is exchanged.